# I3 intelligence-use evaluation: i3-public-data-continuity-v1

Contract: `intelligence-use-receipt-v1`

Recorded 13 receipts. Material: 4; degraded: 3.

> Material influence is not beneficial impact. Benefit remains unsupported until later L1 outcome evidence.

| Task | Intelligence | Highest state | Changed I1 fields | Comparison | Completeness |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| task:i3-material | observation:i3-material | decision-material | alternatives, assumptions, evidence_refs, reconsideration_conditions, scope, selected_option | matched | complete |
| task:i3-null | observation:i3-null | reflected |  | matched | complete |
| task:i3-irrelevant | insight:i3-irrelevant | retrieved |  | matched | complete |
| task:i3-reflected | insight:i3-reflected | reflected |  | matched | complete |
| task:i3-stale | insight:i3-stale | reflected |  | matched | complete |
| task:i3-invalidated | observation:i3-invalidated | retrieved |  | matched | complete |
| task:i3-contested | observation:i3-contested | decision-material | alternatives, assumptions, evidence_refs, reconsideration_conditions, scope, selected_option | matched | complete |
| task:i3-harmful | insight:i3-harmful | decision-material | alternatives, assumptions, evidence_refs, reconsideration_conditions, scope, selected_option | matched | complete |
| task:i3-product-mismatch | insight:i3-foreign | reflected |  | matched | complete |
| task:i3-route-mismatch | observation:i3-route-mismatch | reflected |  | mismatched | degraded |
| task:i3-evaluation-failure | observation:i3-evaluation-failure | reflected |  | failed | degraded |
| task:i3-partial-lineage | insight:i3-partial-lineage | reflected |  | matched | degraded |
| task:i3-restart | observation:i3-restart | decision-material | alternatives, assumptions, evidence_refs, reconsideration_conditions, scope, selected_option | matched | complete |

## Unsupported claims

- Retrieval alone is use.
- A reflected identifier or copied wording proves materiality.
- Cross-provider, cross-model, or configuration-mismatched differences prove a memory effect.
- Decision-material retained intelligence is necessarily beneficial.
- I3 establishes the later L1 beneficial-impact claim.

## Limitations

- The deterministic matrix tests contract semantics, not general model quality.
- The authoritative live route is the existing supported Codex subscription evidence; no new provider work was started.
- Beneficial impact, reliability, and longitudinal quality remain gated on L1 outcome evidence.
